[問題]大全987-Q63

[mcpopcorn2001]

63. After July, anyone disposing of or servicing refrigerators must capture the chlorofluorocarbons in the refrigerant chemicals.
(A) anyone disposing of or servicing
(B) those who dispose or service
(C) anyone disposing of or who services
(D) the disposal or repair of
(E) someone who disposes or repairs

答案 a
我選 e 請問一下錯在哪呢?
是repair改變句意嗎? 那service在這裡是做什麼意思哀?

[Frankts]

根據題目的意思 主詞應該為人 所以不選D
B的those之前沒有提到人讓它帶 所以不好
C的選項不平衡
E的選項 我不確定是否有改變句意 但是覺得有點囉唆
A的選項中 dispose of 是處理的意思 service有維修的意思
因此看起來A選項好像比E好一點

[dibert8]

非劃線部份有一個強烈的字 must, 所以 anyone 會比 someone 的句意好.

[yuyutseng]

63. After July, anyone disposing of or servicing refrigerators must capture the chlorofluorocarbons in the refrigerant chemicals.
(A) anyone disposing of or servicing
(B) those who dispose or service
(C) anyone disposing of or who services
(D) the disposal or repair of
(E) someone who disposes or repairs

答案 a
我選 e 請問一下錯在哪呢?
是repair改變句意嗎? 那service在這裡是做什麼意思哀?

做到這一題也是有點頭大,
後來查了一下字典, 有以下發現
(1)dispose 和dispose of 有不同意思
dispose : to distribute, to regulate, to adjust, to settle, to put in place
dispose of : To determine the fate of; to exercise the power of control over; to fix the condition, application, employment
所以就句意上來說, 好像dispose of 比較適合此題的命題 => 去掉 BDE
(2)anyone disposing of or servicing ... 的意思是任何人OOXX
但是those who dispose or service 的意思應該是那些OOXX的人們
句意好像被改掉了 => 去掉B
(3) C 不對稱, D 主詞不對

雖然刪除的過程很艱辛, 但是刪完以後就剩下A 可以選了.